Welcome to Benny's Pizzeria
Benny's Pizzeria, located at 114 N Church St, West Chester, PA, is a beloved local eatery renowned for its exceptional pizza and welcoming atmosphere. Customers rave about the unique stuffed pizza and flavorful options like buffalo chicken and chicken pesto, all made with fresh ingredients. The friendly staff enhance the experience, making patrons feel at home. With a legacy of nostalgia and comfort, diners appreciate not only the diverse menu—featuring delicious cheesesteaks and chicken tenders—but also the affordable prices. Benny's Pizzeria is more than just a meal; it's a cherished spot that fosters community and lasting memories.
Benny's Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
Benny's is my favorite pizza in West Chester. They not only provide excellent food at a great price, but they serve you with a smile and their down to earth attitude makes you feel welcomed into the store. One of my favorite small businesses in all of WC. If you haven't tried their unique stuffed pizza, you are missing out. I would have posted pictures, but I couldn't wait to eat while I typed this. Keep it up Matt, and the rest of the crew
Pizza is amazing, fresh ingredients and the crust is amazing! This visit I had the buffalo chicken and the chicken pesto, I was starving! Flavorful and so yummy! Not bad for about 8 and change. I’m partial to blue cheese in my buffalo chicken pizza, but I think that’s all that’s missing! Service was quick and pleasant, especially for a Friday.
If you live on the West Coast for more than a decade, chances are you have had some really had pizza, some good ones, and really miss your hometown favorite. West Chester isn’t where I grew up, but Benny’s is my comfort food. The pizza is my style, the cheesesteaks are legit, the prices are a steal. This is my go to Friday family spot.
I adore Bennys!! It’s been around since my dad was a kid (he’s 67) and he took me here almost every week after my basketball games. I love stopping in for a slice!! The sweet sauce is good, I love that they have a variety of pizza by the slice, their chicken tenders, tots, and other menu items never disappoint. The employees are as sweet as can be. This place makes me feel so nostalgic and happy I hope it’s around forever
We love Benny’s! Food is amazing, and the staff are so kind and generous. We just moved right down the road from here and plan to make it our go-to pizza spot! I wanted to add to ask for the Grandmom pizza. Best pizza I’ve ever had-hands down!
Great staff and pizza. Super crispy and large slices were awesome!
Went here for a quick bite to eat and we were very impressed! The pizza was delicious The guy at the counter was nice and pleasent. He hooked me up with plates to go! I would definitely recommend giving this place a shot ...
My favorite pizza in town since I came to WC in the 90s. Thankfully it has never changed. If you like thin and burnt, this isn't for you. But it's not too thick either. They use very good quality cheese that has a great flavor and doesn't bubble or get greasy.
Location
-
114 N Church St, West Chester, PA 19380, United States Hotline: +1 610-696-0754
Welcome to Benny's Pizzeria, your new favorite destination for delicious pizza in the heart of West Chester, Pennsylvania. Tucked away at 114 N Church St, this charming pizzeria has been delighting locals with their comforting and flavorful offerings. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with a warm smile that reflects the welcoming atmosphere that Benny's embodies.
The magic of Benny's lies not only in their mouthwatering pizzas but also in their dedication to using fresh ingredients. As one customer, Tiffany Marron, puts it, "Pizza is amazing, fresh ingredients and the crust is amazing!" Whether you opt for the adventurous buffalo chicken or the aromatic chicken pesto, each slice promises a burst of flavors that will leave you craving more. And with prices that won't break the bank, indulging in a hearty meal here feels like a steal.
Benny's remarkable stuffed pizza is a standout favorite that you simply can't miss. As Gene B. points out, if you haven't tried it yet, you're truly missing out. The combination of textures and tastes here is a testament to the craftsmanship and passion that goes into every pie. Their signature Grandmom pizza has also garnered rave reviews, with many claiming it's the best pizza they've ever had.
This pizzeria is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a cornerstone of the community and a piece of nostalgia for many. Julie fondly recalls visiting Benny's with her father after basketball games, highlighting the tradition and warmth that this establishment radiates. It’s a place where memories are made, and families come together—just as Kenneth Smith describes, it's his go-to spot for family Fridays.
The cheerful and attentive staff add to the overall experience, ensuring every visit is pleasant and memorable. From the chicken tenders to the crispy tots, Benny's menu caters to every craving, making it the ideal spot for a casual hangout or a family meal.
So, whether you’re a long-time local or a first-time visitor, Benny's Pizzeria invites you to savor the taste of their expertly crafted pizzas and the spirit of community they’ve cultivated. Don't wait—dive into a slice of happiness at Benny's today!